Philotic Web

What did you think?

This didn't feel like an OSC/Ender book at all to me. I didn't like it at all.

I also don't like the idea of turning EG into a graphic novel because it cuts out a lot of the important bits.

Haven't read it, but a much expanded novel version of this story is in the works by OSC and Aaron Johnson, called "Earth Unaware".

I also don't like the idea of turning EG into a graphic novel because it cuts out a lot of the important bits.

It condenses the story, yes, but it's a different medium and having read all but the latest release, I thought it did well converting the story. There are some parts that would make little to no sense if you hadn't read the books first but I think they're strong enough to push people towards the books.